Balanced Regional Development through District Planning – A comparative analysis of Indian and South African planning frameworks

This abstract has open access
Abstract Summary
Regional planning literature suggest development of small and medium sized cities to counter balance mega-city-centric growth poles. Yet, implementations of such strategies are problematic, especially in fast growing transitional economies of the Global South. Market driven global economic environment typically favours metropolitan scale, connectivity and human resource talent pool, in channelizing investment generations. Moreover, newly industrializing countries often lack institutional and technical capacities to undertake integrated regional planning. This paper compare and contrast approach towards balanced regional development through district planning in India and South Africa to draw policy lessons. Employment generation for surplus rural labour has become a crucial developmental challenge for both India and South Africa. Despite achieving impressive GDP growth rates, both the countries are suffering from job crisis. Youth unemployment rate of South Africa is 52.15 percent; while in India, official unemployment rate is 7.2 percent, but under employment is over 30 percent, as millions of people, are stuck in low skill-low wage casual jobs. Rural urban income differentials are high. Rural youth are migrating to big cities, but low skilled jobs are only available at the bottom tier of the urban informal labour market. To redress rural—urban dichotomy, both the countries had sought to undertake regional planning at a district level, and district plans are seen as integrative platform for urban and rural area plans and sectoral agencies of the provincial government. In India District Planning process was institutionalised as part of a wider process of state restructuring and decentralisationunder the74th Constitutional Amendment Acts of 1992. District Planning is a mandatory statutory activity; but its implementation had been slow and uneven. Considerable state-wise variation exists in the planning process as well as its institutional arrangements. In states where properly implemented, District Planning has become an integral part of the participatory planning, gender empowerment, spatial targeting of developmental grants and disaster risk mitigation. India has also undertaken pilot project to develop 30 rurbun clusters to encourage skill development and training for artisans and handicraft sector. Compared to the Indian district planning model’s emphasis on social equity through participatory planning, the South Africa's district planning approach is more top-down and has stronger emphasis on economic issues. South Africa’s innovative Spatial Planning and Land Use Management Act (SPLUMA) of 2013 has sought revive rural and small town economies by building logistics networks and product value chains for agro-processing sectors connecting different settlement hierarchies. It has also built in mechanism to harmonize strategic business plan with land use planning and infrastructure development. The comparative analysis of two major transitional economies shows potential of district planning to achieve balanced regional development. It also underscores the need for the regional planning mechanism to combine features of top-down strategic approach and bottom-up participatory approach
Abstract ID :
ISO119
Submission Type
Draft presentation :

Similar Abstracts by Type

Abstract ID
Abstract Title
Abstract Topic
Submission Type
Primary Author
ISO542
360cityscan: integrated solutions to face urban challenges
6: Changing environment and risks: planning for resilience
Draft Presentation
Mattias Vansteenwegen
ISO406
A comparative study of the application of the Storm Water Management Model in the construction of urban green space under the perspectives of sponge cities —— Case Study of Lakeside Greenway Park, Qi` an, China
5: Smart futures and sustainability: planning for innovation
Draft Presentation
MING SHAO
ISO254
An assessment and delineation of Socio-economic Resilience Landscapes of the Region based on the inherent latent factors of vulnerabilities
6: Changing environment and risks: planning for resilience
Draft Presentation
Ms Shivangi Singh Parmar
ISO611
Anticipation Strategy for Urban Conurbation in Semarang - Surabaya Corridor
2: Beside the megacity and the role of other cities and areas: planning for balance
Draft Presentation
Dwitantri Rezkiandini Lestari
ISO354
Association between Neighborhood Built Environment and Body Mass Index among Chinese Adults: Hierarchical Linear Model
3: Liveable places and healthy cities: planning for people
Draft Presentation
Miss Mengqi Zhong
ISO119
Balanced Regional Development through District Planning – A comparative analysis of Indian and South African planning frameworks
2: Beside the megacity and the role of other cities and areas: planning for balance
Draft Presentation
Prof Tathagata Chatterji
ISO380
Breaking the lock-in of regional governance: A case study of cross-boundary coordinating planning in Yangtze Delta
7: Urban governance and planning profession: planning for future
Draft Presentation
Jianshuang Hu
ISO488
CHILDREN SENSE OF PLACE IN A TYPICAL TRADITIONAL AFRICAN CITY
3: Liveable places and healthy cities: planning for people
Draft Presentation
Deborah OJO
ISO649
Community responses to displacement threats in flood prone areas. The case of Ciliwung River, Jakarta
6: Changing environment and risks: planning for resilience
Draft Presentation
Ms Anastasia Widyaningsih

Similar Abstracts by Topic

Abstract ID
Abstract Title
Abstract Topic
Submission Type
Primary Author
ISO532
A blessing or a curse? Transforming oil cities to innovative green urban economy. A comparative study between two Indonesian cities and Stavanger
5: Smart futures and sustainability: planning for innovation
Case Study/Research Project
Ari Krisna Mawira Tarigan
ISO406
A comparative study of the application of the Storm Water Management Model in the construction of urban green space under the perspectives of sponge cities —— Case Study of Lakeside Greenway Park, Qi` an, China
5: Smart futures and sustainability: planning for innovation
Draft Presentation
MING SHAO
ISO473
Assessing the spatio-temporal change of air quality and finding their correlation with urban activities
5: Smart futures and sustainability: planning for innovation
Paper
Swechcha Roy
ISO80
Automated vehicles in Latin American cities? feasibility of adoption, impacts on urban structure and public policies
5: Smart futures and sustainability: planning for innovation
Paper
Cynthia Goytia
ISO541
Big data based assessment on metropolisation processes in Poland
5: Smart futures and sustainability: planning for innovation
Paper
Hanna Obracht-Prondzyńska
ISO619
Cellular Automata: A Spatial Method to Identified Land Use Change Modeling (Case Study: Tembalang District, Semarang, Indonesia
5: Smart futures and sustainability: planning for innovation
Full Paper
Zenia F Saraswati
ISO149
Cellular Payloads and Urban Context : Unmeasured Complexity. The Case of Amol, Mazandaran Province, Iran
5: Smart futures and sustainability: planning for innovation
Case Study/Research Project
raana saffari
ISO545
Cities and Digitization: Perspectives and Challenges of the Smart City Technologies on Urban Planning and Design
5: Smart futures and sustainability: planning for innovation
Session Proposal
Prof Junyan YANG
ISO129
Comprehensive Evaluation and Dynamic Evolution Analysis of Shanghai’s Urban Vulnerability
5: Smart futures and sustainability: planning for innovation
Draft Presentation
Miss Tian Qin